Breaking News
UnitedHealth falls 5.4% after Warren calls for health care breakups
Sen. Elizabeth Warren backed a bill that would bar insurers and drug-plan middlemen from owning care providers, naming UnitedHealth. The company lost $20 billion in market value, and a health care sector fund slid 1.4%. The question is whether the bill advances in Congress.
At Tuesday’s close: S&P 500 −1.03%, Nasdaq-100 −0.72%, Dow −1.64%
Quick Read
- UnitedHealth shares tumbled 5.4% Tuesday after Sen. Elizabeth Warren called for breaking up health care conglomerates and named the company.
- Warren and Sen. Josh Hawley back a bill that would bar insurers, PBMs and wholesale drug distributors from owning or controlling care providers.
- The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services separately proposed a fraud rule that would tighten provider screening and oversight of Medicare Advantage plans.
- Both the bill and the rule are proposals; whether either advances may shape how long the pressure on the shares lasts.
How far did UnitedHealth shares fall?
UnitedHealth Group shares tumbled 5.4% on Tuesday and closed at $389.69. The previous close was $412.02.
Why it matters: The drop erased $20 billion of the company's market value, which is the total worth of all its shares. That left UnitedHealth valued at $350 billion. Investors traded $2.5 billion of the stock during the session.
By the numbers: The shares now sit 10.7% below their 52-week high of $436.35, the highest price they reached over the past year.
The wider market fell too. The S&P 500 slid 1.0%, and a fund holding only health care stocks (XLV) fell 1.4%, a bigger drop than the broad index.
What did Warren say about breaking up insurers?
Warren called for breaking up the largest health care conglomerates. She named UnitedHealth, CVS Health and The Cigna Group. She said these companies "take a cut at every step."
Her target is vertical integration. That is when one company owns an insurer, a pharmacy benefit manager and pharmacies. A pharmacy benefit manager, or PBM, is a middleman that runs prescription drug plans.
She pointed to the Break Up Big Medicine Act, which she introduced with Sen. Josh Hawley, a Missouri Republican. The bill would bar health insurers, PBMs and wholesale drug distributors from owning or controlling health care providers.
Warren has also criticized UnitedHealth's purchase of Amedisys. She argued the deal could give the insurer more influence over patient care and costs. The Justice Department settled its challenge to that deal on terms that required the sale of locations across multiple states.
What did Medicare's regulator propose?
Separately, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) proposed a rule it calls CRUSH. It targets fraud, waste and abuse in federal health programs. CMS said the proposal could save taxpayers money.
The rule would tighten provider screening, improve fraud reporting and require more disclosure of who owns providers. It would give regulators more power to deny or revoke a provider's enrollment.
It also seeks tighter oversight of Medicare Advantage plans, the private plans that deliver Medicare benefits. It would add stronger enforcement against agents and brokers involved in abusive Marketplace sign-ups.
What could happen next for health insurers?
What’s next: Both measures are proposals. The bill would become law only after passing the Senate and the House and getting the president's signature. The CMS rule was proposed, not finalized.
The open question for shareholders is whether the bill draws enough votes to advance in Congress. Another question is whether CMS adopts its rule as proposed. Each step would show how much of the structure Warren criticized could actually change.
For readers
What it could mean for you: If you own UnitedHealth shares directly, the company's news reaches you in full, with no other holdings to soften it. The Break Up Big Medicine Act targets the kind of combination of insurer, drug-plan middleman and care provider that Warren criticized UnitedHealth for. If the bill gains support in Congress, that worry could weigh on the shares for longer; if it stalls, it may fade. CMS's push for tighter oversight of Medicare Advantage plans could also matter to insurers that offer them.
Questions and answers
Why did UnitedHealth stock fall on Tuesday?
Sen. Elizabeth Warren called for breaking up large health care conglomerates and named UnitedHealth, CVS Health and Cigna. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services also proposed tighter fraud rules the same day.
What is the Break Up Big Medicine Act?
It is a bill introduced by Sen. Elizabeth Warren and Sen. Josh Hawley. It would bar health insurers, pharmacy benefit managers and wholesale drug distributors from owning or controlling health care providers.
What is the CMS CRUSH rule?
It is a proposed rule from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services aimed at fraud, waste and abuse in Medicare, Medicaid, CHIP and the Health Insurance Marketplace. It would tighten provider screening, require more ownership disclosure and add oversight of Medicare Advantage plans.
The numbers
| UNITEDHEALTH GROUP INCORPORATED (Delaware) (UNH) price | $389.69 |
|---|---|
| UNITEDHEALTH GROUP INCORPORATED (Delaware) (UNH) change | −5.42% |
| UNITEDHEALTH GROUP INCORPORATED (Delaware) (UNH) market value | $350 billion |
| UNITEDHEALTH GROUP INCORPORATED (Delaware) (UNH) 52-week high | $436.35 |
| S&P 500 change | −1.03% |
| 10-year Treasury yield | 5.10% |
Tuesday’s close
Companies in this story
Share this story
The WallStreetDigest daily arrives at 6:15 a.m. ET every trading day.
Not investment advice.